Eibach Stage 1 vs Stage 2R: In-Depth Toyota Tundra Suspension Comparison

Posted by Sean Reyes on

We recently had the opportunity to work with Jeff, who has been extensively testing Eibach's suspension systems on his new Tundra. After months of testing the Stage 1 kit, we helped him upgrade to the Stage 2R system, and the differences are noteworthy.

The Test Vehicle: A Do-It-All Tundra

Jeff's Tundra serves as the ultimate family adventure vehicle. Whether it's hauling dirt bikes, towing a side-by-side trailer, or taking the family on trail adventures, this truck needs to do it all.

The current setup includes:

  • 315/70/17 tires
  • Method MR318 wheels with +25 offset
  • Basic lighting upgrades

Breaking Down the Stage 1 Kit

The Stage 1 kit includes:

  • Eibach front and rear shocks
  • Front and rear springs
  • Expected lift measurements:
    • Rear: 1.1 inches
    • Front: 2.6 inches (with potential for 3.2 inches, though not recommended)

Stage 1 Performance Review

While the Stage 1 kit offers decent performance in some areas, Jeff's experience revealed some limitations. The positive aspects included excellent handling characteristics and impressive small bump compliance. However, the system showed its weaknesses when pushed harder, particularly in the front end where frequent topping out became an issue.

The root cause? The Stage 1 struts share similar dimensions with stock TRD Off-Road components, limiting available droop travel to around two inches. While the ride height did settle slightly after a couple of months of use, adding cargo or taking the vehicle off-road amplified the suspension's limitations.

Stepping Up to Stage 2 and Stage 2R

What's Included

  • Stage 2: Everything from Stage 1, plus front coilovers
  • Stage 2R: Adds reservoir rear shocks to the Stage 2 package

One of Eibach's strengths is their modular approach - components can be purchased individually, making gradual upgrades possible without financial penalty. The coilover upgrade alone can be purchased separately for Stage 1 owners looking to improve their setup.

Key Improvements

The Stage 2 coilovers offer significant advantages:

  • Adjustable lift from 0.8 to 3.2 inches
  • Approximately 6 inches more shock length
  • Nearly an inch more wheel travel
  • Better droop travel even at maximum lift compared to Stage 1 at minimum lift
  • Pre-loaded design eliminates the need for spring compressors
  • Fine-tunable ride height adjustments while installed

The Stage 2R Advantage

The reservoir rear shocks in the Stage 2R kit provide:

  • More linear piston design vs. the digressive valving in non-reservoir shocks
  • Enhanced comfort for off-road use
  • Improved bottoming control
  • Better heat management

Technical Considerations

For Tundra owners considering these upgrades, it's important to note the axle configurations:

  • Base models: Black axles with tripod design
  • TRD Off-Road and Pro: Red axles with Rzeppa joints
  • TRD Silver: Extended version of the red axles

While the Stage 2 system should work with black axles, we strongly recommend adding a differential drop kit for $35. This affordable upgrade helps prevent binding, especially with larger tires, and simplifies installation.

Final Thoughts

The upgrade from Stage 1 to Stage 2R represents a significant improvement in suspension performance and capability. While the Stage 1 kit offers a solid entry point, the Stage 2R's additional travel, improved valving, and superior heat management make it the clear choice for those who frequently take their Tundras off-road or demand maximum performance from their suspension system.

For those starting their suspension upgrade journey, we recommend going straight to Stage 2 if budget allows. The improved performance and versatility make it worth the additional investment. However, Eibach's modular approach means you can start with Stage 1 and upgrade later without any financial penalty.

More To Read

Lifted Shocks and Leveling Struts vs. Strut Spacers - Pros, Cons, and Risks
Pros and Cons of Strut Spacers There are pros and cons to each option, the biggest factor for peo...
How Much Does It Cost to Replace Shock Absorbers? Answers from an Insider
If you have a general feeling of uneasiness or being thrown around on the streets or highways, or...
Frequently Asked Questions About Falcon Shocks
Are Falcon shocks any good? Falcon shocks are designed and built by the team behind Teraflex Susp...
The Lowdown: Bilstein 6112 vs. Fox 2.0 Performance Coilovers
With the release of Bilstein's newest suspension setup for late model trucks, the incredibly thic...
Skyjacker Black Max Shocks are Tuned for Comfort
A lot of customers call in with similar stories, “I put a lift on my truck and the shocks that ca...